Well Mothers wheel polish didn’t do anything, thinking of trying some paint buffing compound I have and if that don’t work it’s getting that WD40 & Steel Wool treatment
Jerry (and that article) said you have to remove the anodizing first or it won't polish up.
At least that's how I read it.
Drop it in a bath of water and one tablespoon drano. Wipe it down and reinsert in bath 2 or 3 times and that should remove the old dull anodizing.
Then polish it and either wax or clearcoat it
-----------
All you need to de-anodize your piece of aluminum is a shallow pan large enough in which to lay it. You'll need warm water, rubber gloves, eye protection and, of
course the drain cleaner. Fill the pan with enough warm water to cover the piece and then add enough drain cleaner to do the job — we find that 1 tablespoon of
cleaner to one gallon of water will de-anodize a couple pieces like headlight bezels.
Watch the bubbles form on the aluminum and lift it out every minute or so to remove the accumulated "smut." Smut is the chemical residue that forms during
the de-anodizing process and you want to remove it periodically to expose the surface to the chemical.
After a few minutes you will see that the piece is a uniform, flat color. Stains and blemishes should have disappeared, leaving only scratches. Take the piece out and
rinse thoroughly with fresh water. Dry it off and inspect for any residual anodized spots, which show up as darker surface finish. If there are any, immerse the piece
in the chemical for a little longer and rub them out. Rinse and dry again.